16Hit1600
AlgebraVery hardFind parameter making a linear equation have no solution

Algebra practice question

A sign at a train museum's exhibit on railway mathematics poses the following puzzle, where k is a constant: 6(2x + 5) - 4x = 3(kx - 2) + 11x. The sign states that the equation has no solution.

What is the value of k?

  1. A. -3
  2. B. -1Correct
  3. C. 1
  4. D. 8/3

Answer: B. -1

The left side simplifies to 12x + 30 - 4x = 8x + 30. The right side simplifies to 3kx - 6 + 11x = (3k + 11)x - 6. An equation of the form ax + b = cx + d has no solution exactly when a = c and b is not equal to d. Setting 3k + 11 = 8 gives 3k = -3, so k = -1; the constants 30 and -6 differ, so there is indeed no solution. (A) -3 results from failing to distribute the 3 to the kx term, solving k + 11 = 8. (C) 1 results from a sign error when solving 3k = -3, treating it as 3k = 3. (D) 8/3 results from ignoring the separate 11x term on the right and solving 3k = 8.

Why the other answers are wrong

A. -3
You solved k + 11 = 8, which means the 3 in 3(kx - 2) never got distributed to the kx term. Distributing gives 3kx, so the coefficient equation is 3k + 11 = 8.
C. 1
Your setup was right, but 3k = -3 gives k = -1, not 1 — check the sign when you divide.
D. 8/3
You set 3k = 8, ignoring the separate 11x on the right side. The full right-side coefficient of x is 3k + 11, and that must equal 8.

More Algebra questions

Not affiliated with the College Board. SAT is a trademark of the College Board.