16Hit1600
Problem-Solving and Data AnalysisVery hardRepeated proportional dilution (percent concentration)

Problem-Solving and Data Analysis practice question

A tank holds 24 liters of a solution that is 35% acid by volume. A technician drains x liters of the solution from the full tank and replaces it with x liters of pure water, mixing thoroughly. The technician then repeats this exact procedure once more on the resulting 24 liters, again draining x liters and replacing it with x liters of pure water. After the second replacement, the solution in the tank is 22.4% acid by volume.

What is the value of x?

  1. A. 4.32
  2. B. 4.8Correct
  3. C. 8.64
  4. D. 9.6

Answer: B. 4.8

Each replacement keeps the fraction (24 − x)/24 of whatever acid is present, since the drained portion has the same concentration as the whole tank and the tank is refilled to 24 liters. After two replacements the concentration is 0.35[(24 − x)/24]² = 0.224, so [(24 − x)/24]² = 0.64 and (24 − x)/24 = 0.8. Then 24 − x = 19.2, so x = 4.8. (C) 8.64 comes from treating the situation as a single replacement: 0.35(24 − x) = 0.224(24) gives x = 8.64. (A) 4.32 is that single-replacement value split in half, as if the two identical steps simply divided one total drain evenly. (D) 9.6 is 2x, the total volume drained over both steps, which is not what the question asks for.

Why the other answers are wrong

A. 4.32
This is 8.64 ÷ 2, treating the two replacements as splitting one total drain evenly. Each step multiplies the acid by the factor (24 − x)/24, so the correct setup is 0.35[(24 − x)/24]² = 0.224.
C. 8.64
You solved as if there were only one replacement: 0.35(24 − x) = 0.224(24). The procedure happens twice, so the retention factor must be squared.
D. 9.6
That's 2x, the total volume drained across both steps. The question asks for x, the amount drained in a single replacement.

More Problem-Solving and Data Analysis questions

Not affiliated with the College Board. SAT is a trademark of the College Board.