16Hit 1600
Information and IdeasMediumSupporting a claim about a poet's revisions of sound

Information and Ideas practice question

Scholars of the poet Halina Mroz contend that her revisions were governed by sound above sense — that a line survived only if it passed the test of the speaking voice. ____

Which quotation from the work most effectively illustrates the claim?

  1. A. "Read every draft aloud," she advised a student. "The ear will refuse lines the eye has already approved."Correct
  2. B. "I compose mainly in the winter months, when the house is quiet."
  3. C. "My publisher has asked for a collected edition next spring."
  4. D. "I keep my drafts in a tin box that belonged to my father."

Answer: A. "Read every draft aloud," she advised a student. "The ear will refuse lines the eye has already approved."

The claim is that she tested revisions by ear; her advice makes the ear the final judge over the eye — direct evidence of sound-driven revision.

Why the other answers are wrong

B. "I compose mainly in the winter months, when the house is quiet."
When she composed says nothing about judging lines by sound.
C. "My publisher has asked for a collected edition next spring."
A publisher's request is unrelated to revision method.
D. "I keep my drafts in a tin box that belonged to my father."
Where drafts are stored shows sentiment, not method.

More Information and Ideas questions

Not affiliated with the College Board. SAT is a trademark of the College Board.