16Hit1600
Information and IdeasVery hardCentral idea of a passage weighing a loss and a gain

Information and Ideas practice question

When the branch line closed in 1966, the village lost its station and gained, within a decade, its silence: no trains, no shunting at six, no coal smuts on the washing. The people who remember the trains miss them; their children, who grew up with the silence, would fight to keep it. Neither is wrong. The line's closure was a loss to one generation and an inheritance to the next, and the village is the sum of both.

Which choice best states the main idea of the text?

  1. A. The same change was a loss for one generation and a benefit for the next, and both views are valid.Correct
  2. B. The branch line should be reopened.
  3. C. Silence is better than trains.
  4. D. The older generation is wrong to miss the trains.

Answer: A. The same change was a loss for one generation and a benefit for the next, and both views are valid.

Loss and inheritance; 'neither is wrong'.

Why the other answers are wrong

B. The branch line should be reopened.
Not argued.
C. Silence is better than trains.
Only for the younger generation.
D. The older generation is wrong to miss the trains.
'Neither is wrong.'

More Information and Ideas questions

Not affiliated with the College Board. SAT is a trademark of the College Board.