16Hit1600
Information and IdeasEasy–MediumInferring a cause from a change

Information and Ideas practice question

The lighthouse logbook records fewer than a dozen ships passing the headland in the whole of 1890. In 1895 it records more than three hundred. A railway line connecting the harbour town to the interior had opened in 1892.

Based on the text, which statement is most reasonable?

  1. A. The railway's arrival increased the shipping traffic through the harbour.Correct
  2. B. The railway caused ships to avoid the harbour.
  3. C. The lighthouse was built in 1895.
  4. D. The logbook for 1890 was lost.

Answer: A. The railway's arrival increased the shipping traffic through the harbour.

Shipping jumped from under a dozen to over three hundred, and the one change the text mentions in between is the railway. Goods arriving by rail would need ships to carry them onward — the most reasonable link.

Why the other answers are wrong

B. The railway caused ships to avoid the harbour.
Traffic ROSE after the railway opened, so the railway didn't drive ships away.
C. The lighthouse was built in 1895.
The logbook records 1890, so the lighthouse existed well before 1895.
D. The logbook for 1890 was lost.
The text quotes the 1890 logbook's figures, so it wasn't lost.

More Information and Ideas questions

Not affiliated with the College Board. SAT is a trademark of the College Board.