16Hit1600
Information and IdeasHardCommand of textual evidence

Information and Ideas practice question

A student claims that the author of a passage views urban rooftop gardens as beneficial to city life.

Which quotation from the passage would best support the student's claim?

  1. A. "Rooftop gardens require regular watering and maintenance."
  2. B. "By cooling buildings and cleaning the air, rooftop gardens make cities more livable."Correct
  3. C. "Some cities have thousands of unused rooftops."
  4. D. "Rooftop gardening dates back to ancient civilizations."

Answer: B. "By cooling buildings and cleaning the air, rooftop gardens make cities more livable."

The claim is that the author sees rooftop gardens as beneficial. Only B states a benefit ('make cities more livable'). A notes a drawback; C and D are neutral facts that don't show a positive view.

Why the other answers are wrong

A. "Rooftop gardens require regular watering and maintenance."
Watering and maintenance is a cost or drawback — the opposite of the positive view the student is claiming.
C. "Some cities have thousands of unused rooftops."
Unused rooftops is a neutral fact about available space; it never says gardens do anything good for the city.
D. "Rooftop gardening dates back to ancient civilizations."
The age of the practice is a neutral historical detail — being ancient isn't the same as being beneficial to city life.

More Information and Ideas questions

Not affiliated with the College Board. SAT is a trademark of the College Board.