16Hit1600
Expression of IdeasEasyRhetorical synthesis: emphasizing a contrast between two subjects

Expression of Ideas practice question

While researching a topic, a student has taken the following notes: • The charango and the siku are two instruments used in Andean folk music. • The charango is a small stringed instrument. • The charango typically has 10 strings. • The siku is a type of panpipe. • The siku is made from hollow reed tubes of varying lengths.

The student wants to emphasize a difference between the charango and the siku. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?

  1. A. The charango is a small stringed instrument with about 10 strings, whereas the siku is a panpipe made from hollow reed tubes of varying lengths.Correct
  2. B. Both the charango and the siku are instruments used in Andean folk music.
  3. C. The charango, a small instrument that typically has about 10 strings, is used in Andean folk music.
  4. D. The siku, a type of panpipe, is made from hollow reed tubes of varying lengths.

Answer: A. The charango is a small stringed instrument with about 10 strings, whereas the siku is a panpipe made from hollow reed tubes of varying lengths.

A is correct: it names both instruments and contrasts them directly (stringed instrument with 10 strings vs. panpipe made of reed tubes), which is exactly what the goal requires. B fails because it states a similarity rather than a difference. C describes only the charango, so no comparison is made. D describes only the siku, so again no difference is drawn between the two instruments.

Why the other answers are wrong

B. Both the charango and the siku are instruments used in Andean folk music.
This states what the two instruments have in common rather than how they differ, which is the opposite of the goal.
C. The charango, a small instrument that typically has about 10 strings, is used in Andean folk music.
You used only the charango notes — with nothing said about the siku, there's no difference being drawn.
D. The siku, a type of panpipe, is made from hollow reed tubes of varying lengths.
You used only the siku notes; a contrast requires information about both instruments in the same sentence.

More Expression of Ideas questions

Not affiliated with the College Board. SAT is a trademark of the College Board.