16Hit1600
Information and IdeasHardChoosing a quotation that illustrates a claim

Information and Ideas practice question

A student claims that the narrator of a memoir finds the city both exhausting and impossible to leave.

Which quotation from the memoir would best support the student's claim?

  1. A. "By nightfall the noise had hollowed me out, and still I walked back into it."Correct
  2. B. "The trains ran late all that week."
  3. C. "I moved to the coast the following spring and never returned."
  4. D. "The city has more than eight million people."

Answer: A. "By nightfall the noise had hollowed me out, and still I walked back into it."

Both halves of the claim are in one line: 'hollowed me out' is exhaustion, and 'still I walked back into it' is the pull the narrator can't resist.

Why the other answers are wrong

B. "The trains ran late all that week."
Late trains are an inconvenience, not the narrator's feelings about the city.
C. "I moved to the coast the following spring and never returned."
Leaving and never returning contradicts 'impossible to leave'.
D. "The city has more than eight million people."
A population figure says nothing about the narrator's feelings.

More Information and Ideas questions

Not affiliated with the College Board. SAT is a trademark of the College Board.